How to migrate a WordPress site without losing Google rankings
You lose rankings in a migration for boring reasons, not mysterious ones. URLs change and nothing redirects them. The new theme rewrites every page title. A noindex tag from the staging copy goes live. The sitemap still points at the old site. None of these are hard to prevent; they are just easy to forget when the exciting part is the new design. This is the process we use on every website migration, and you can use it as a checklist whether you hire us or not.
1. Crawl the old site and write everything down
Before a single file moves, crawl the whole site with Screaming Frog (free up to 500 URLs, enough for most small business sites). Export every URL with its title, H1, meta description, canonical and word count. This is your inventory. Anything not on this list does not exist as far as the migration is concerned, so make sure the crawl includes images, PDFs and the odd pages a plugin created that you forgot about.
2. List what actually ranks and what links to you
Open Google Search Console, Performance report, last twelve months, and export pages by clicks. Those are the pages that pay the bills; they get special attention. Then pull your backlinks from Search Console’s Links report or a tool like Ahrefs. A page with inbound links must keep its URL or get a redirect, or the link value is thrown away on the day you switch.
3. Write the URL map, one line per page
A spreadsheet: old URL in column A, new URL in column B. Keep as many URLs identical as you can; a URL that does not change needs no redirect and carries no risk. Where a URL must change, decide the new one now, not on launch night. If the new site drops pages, map each dropped page to the closest relevant page, never to the homepage in bulk. Google treats mass redirects to the homepage as soft 404s and the value is lost.
4. Build on a private address
Build the new site on a staging subdomain or a local copy that is password-protected or noindexed. Move the content across and keep the page titles, H1s and meta descriptions from your inventory. The most common silent damage in a migration is a new theme that generates its own titles and overwrites a decade of carefully written ones. Check the inventory against the new site before launch, page by page for the ones that rank.
5. Carry the technical signals across
Canonical tags pointing at the new URLs. An XML sitemap that lists only the new URLs. Schema markup re-implemented, not left in the old theme. Analytics and Search Console verification on the new site. Internal links updated to the new URLs rather than relying on redirects to catch them. Images with the same alt text. If you are changing hosts, test the contact forms and email delivery on the staging copy, because a form that posts to nowhere is a migration failure you will not see in any SEO tool.
6. Set a 301 for every changed URL
From your map, create a 301 redirect for every URL in column A that differs from column B. On WordPress the Redirection plugin handles this; on a server level, the .htaccess or Nginx config. Use 301, not 302, and redirect one-to-one, not to the homepage. Then test them. Paste the old URLs into a crawler as a list and confirm every one returns a 301 to the right destination and the destination returns 200. Chains (old to middle to new) and loops are the usual errors.
7. Switch with no downtime
Lower the DNS TTL a day before. Put the new site live, remove the staging noindex, and switch DNS in a quiet hour. Run the redirect test again on the live domain, because a redirect that worked on staging can break when the domain changes. Submit the new sitemap in Search Console. If the domain changed, use the Change of Address tool as well, and keep the old domain registered and redirecting for at least a year.
8. Watch it for thirty days
Check Search Console’s Coverage and Pages reports daily for the first week for crawl errors, 404s and “excluded by noindex”. Check clicks for your top pages against the export from step two. A wobble of a week or two is normal while Google recrawls; a drop that lasts a month means something on this list was missed, and the list tells you where to look. We check at launch and again at thirty days on every migration and send the client a written note.
What this costs if you hire it out
A platform migration, for example Wix or Squarespace to WordPress, with every step above starts at $2,000 and takes three to four weeks at Soofi Digital. A host or domain move with no design change starts at $750 and takes about a week. A migration with a new design starts at $3,500 as redesign and migration. All of those are starting prices in US dollars, on our pricing page, with a fixed written quote after a free call.
The mistakes we see most
Changing URLs for tidiness. The new agency wants /services/plumbing/ instead of /plumbing-services/ and nobody asks whether the old one ranked. Launching with the staging noindex still on; it happens on sites with budgets you would not believe. Redirecting an entire old blog to the homepage. Letting the new theme write titles. Forgetting that the old site had a PDF with 40 backlinks. And skipping the thirty-day watch, so the drop is found in month three when the quarterly numbers come in and the agency has moved on.
If your migration is coming up and you want it done this way, book a free 30-minute call and bring your Search Console login. The first thing we will do is step two.
Want a second opinion on your own site?
Send us the address and a person will look at it properly, then email you what they find. Free, and there is nothing to buy at the end of it.